2022-2023 Jonathan Dayton Commitment Day Athletes:
| Name | College | Sport |
| Samantha Casey | Misericordia University | Basketball |
| Deanna Dubois | Softball College of Staten Island | Softball |
| Taylor Gollin | Wilkes University | Soccer |
| Wesley Griffith | Movavian College | Baseball |
| Gianna Hester | William Smith College | Soccer |
| Samantha Janker | Union College | Volleyball |
| Colin Riley | Villanova University | XC/Track |
2023-2024
| Name | College | Sport |
| Alex Altemus | Springfield College | Football |
| Katherine Buckley | Gettysburg College | Softball |
| Megan Kreinberg | Fairleigh Dickinson University | Track + Volleyball |
| Molly Martys | Scranton University | Soccer |
| Natalie Mignone | Drew University | Softball |
| Ja'Mar Onwuzurike | Kean University | Track |
| Peter Ramirez | Rowan University | Baseball |
| Alyssa Santangelo | Muhlenberg College | Softball |